FTI Investigations / Government communications and civil rights
The Words, the Signals, the Policies
How racially charged language, extremist-associated symbols and immigration messaging crossed the first and second Trump administrations—and what the records do, and do not, establish.
The question is not whether every harsh political phrase is secret code. It is whether public officials have repeatedly selected language or imagery with identifiable racial associations, who approved it, and whether those choices carried forward into government decisions.
Read by section
What the records show
In November 2026, a U.S. attorney's formal warning to Sen. Elizabeth Warren invoked Native American imagery in a dispute over planned congressional investigations. Earlier, the White House had attacked Warren with the name “Pocahontas” during the first Trump presidency, prompting public objections from Native American leaders. The words and their official settings are documented; an instruction from the White House to use those images in the 2026 letter is not. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
The broader record also includes federal recruitment advertisements that outside researchers traced to extremist-associated slogans, images or music; released 2017–2018 emails concerning coordination of immigration press messaging; and official policies whose language echoes earlier political speeches. These are related subjects for investigation, not proof that all were designed by one person or to send a covert message. [8] [9] [10] [13] [14] [15] [16]
1. The Warren warning: a comparison across nine years
2017: a Native American name used as a political attack
The National Congress of American Indians objected in May 2017 when President Trump used “Pocahontas” to refer to Warren at an NRA address. The group again objected after Trump repeated the nickname at the White House's November 27 ceremony honoring Navajo Code Talkers. The second incident appears in the archived presidential transcript, and NCAI issued a same-day response emphasizing the veterans and the historical Pocahontas's own legacy. [1] [2] [3]
2026: the stereotypes appear in a prosecutor's letter
U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz sent Warren a preservation demand dated November 15, invoking federal civil-rights statutes and her anticipated congressional oversight. In discussing her future committee work, the letter uses “smoke signal,” “tomahawk,” and “scalps” language—imagery that can reasonably be read in light of the earlier Warren attacks and Native American stereotypes. The original FTI congressional-oversight investigation examines the letter, its deadline and legal claims in greater detail. [4] [5] [6]
The observation is specific: the recurring imagery and target are documented. Reitz's private reason for choosing it, the identity of any other drafter, and whether a senior official approved it before it went public remain unanswered. It would overstate the evidence to say the White House wrote the letter. [4] [6]
November 16: inquiry and professional-conduct complaints
Campaign for Accountability announced a grievance asking the State Bar of Texas to investigate Reitz's letters to Warren and Sen. Richard Blumenthal. It cited professional rules concerning prosecutors' threats of unsupported charges and the misuse of legal process. The grievance is an allegation, not a bar ruling. Reitz rejected it as frivolous and told CBS News he would continue a “preliminary inquiry” into whether some legislators had exceeded their legitimate legislative purpose. DOJ defended First Amendment rights of private individuals. [5] [6]
CBS also reported a separate Reitz letter to Rep. Robert Garcia on November 16, distinct from an earlier warning issued by White House counsel. A second group, The Steady State, asked DOJ to review Reitz's warnings to Blumenthal and Sen. Elissa Slotkin and the White House counsel letter to Garcia. Submission of either request does not establish prosecutorial misconduct, a formal criminal case, or DOJ acceptance of the request. [6] [7]
2. The first administration: from public rhetoric to coordinated messaging
The Miller–Breitbart correspondence, 2015–2016
In 2019, the Southern Poverty Law Center published an analysis of more than 900 emails it said Stephen Miller exchanged with Breitbart editors in 2015–2016. The organization reported examples of Miller recommending anti-immigrant material, including a novel popular in white-nationalist circles. Those reported exchanges are direct evidence of attempts to influence coverage. They are not, without further documents, proof that every later government phrase came from that material. [8]
What released government emails show
FOIA-obtained communications published by American Oversight document Miller's interactions with Steve Bannon, Justice Department aides, Attorney General Jeff Sessions's office, ICE advisers and public-affairs personnel during 2017–2018. The records include meetings about immigration orders, revisions to speeches, promotion of immigrant-crime narratives and planning for agency communication. An ICE adviser discussed coordinating information to shape the narrative. [9] [10] [11]
That is evidence of an actual communications process. It is not evidence that any single racist phrase was commissioned, or that the entire process had an unlawful racial purpose. The next step is to trace individual draft passages from sender to published output.
Three episodes that require their full context
Charlottesville, August 2017. Trump's statements included both language assigning blame to more than one side and an explicit statement that neo-Nazis and white nationalists should be condemned. Reporting should preserve the sequence and not misquote him as explicitly designating neo-Nazis “very fine people.” The words, responses and their surrounding context remain part of the historical record. [27]
“Animals,” May 2018. The initial exchange concerned MS-13, and the administration framed later statements in that specific context. Criticism of dehumanizing language is valid as analysis, but attributing the term to all immigrants as though that were the quoted exchange would be inaccurate. [28]
Proud Boys, September 2020. At a presidential debate, Trump told the group to “stand back and stand by”; the following day he called on the group to stand down. Both remarks are documented and should be examined together, including any independent evidence about how group members interpreted the first wording. [29] [30]
3. The second administration: federal recruitment and symbolic messaging
Between July 2025 and early 2026, immigration-enforcement promotional posts and other federal graphics drew criticism for their resemblance to nationalist and extremist-associated imagery. In some examples the relationship is textual; in others, an identifiable recording was shared. The level of evidence differs.
| Period | Issuer and material | What can be said |
|---|---|---|
| July 2025 | DHS paired a heritage slogan with John Gast's American Progress. | The nineteenth-century painting depicts westward settlement and displacement of Native peoples. Reusing it is documented; the precise intended modern interpretation is contested. [33] |
| Aug. 2025 | DHS/ICE: “Which way, American man?” | Researchers linked the formulation to an antisemitic white-supremacist book and later meme culture. DHS rejected an extremist-intent interpretation. [14] |
| Oct. 2025 | DHS: “America for Americans.” | The formulation has a history of nativist use. Its appearance alone does not establish which historical speaker, if any, the agency intended to reference. [20] [32] |
| Jan. 2026 | DHS and White House: “We'll have our home again.” | Research traced accompanying music to material circulated in white-nationalist networks. This is a stronger provenance lead than phrase resemblance alone; intentional extremist signaling is not established. [15] [16] |
| Jan. 2026 | Labor: “One Homeland. One People. One Heritage.” | Critics noted similarities with Nazi-era rhetorical structure. It is not an identical historic slogan. [16] [17] [32] |
| Jan. 2026 | White House: “Which way, Greenland man?” | The formulation repeated an earlier DHS phrase. Shared production staff or specific instructions remain unknown. [16] |
| Feb. 2026 | Presidential account: video depicting Barack and Michelle Obama as apes. | The racist depiction was public and later removed. Trump said he had not viewed the offensive portion; that explanation and the removal belong in the record. It is overt imagery, not a hidden dog whistle. [26] |
CNN's January 2026 review also found no historical evidence that another phrase, “one of ours, all of yours,” was itself a Nazi slogan. That example is not included here as a proven historical code. A resemblance or an internet claim is not enough. [17]
4. Personnel pathways worth checking
Reporting documented that Peyton Rollins moved from Labor communications work to a DHS digital-communications position in February 2026 after controversy over Labor posts. That establishes an employment link across departments. It does not prove that Rollins designed any particular DHS recruiting image. [18]
Other reporting described the earlier public statements of DHS speechwriter Eric Lendrum, including his promotion of a “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory. His role is relevant to the department's communications environment, but no original post in this evidence set can be assigned to him solely because he worked there. [19]
The first-administration paper trail suggests questions for the current one: Who provided the text? Who selected the artwork and music? Was there agency or contractor review? Were officials alerted to the extremist associations before publication? Shared ideology is not a substitute for a dated production record.
5. Where language becomes policy
“Invasion”: 2018 political language, 2025 presidential proclamation
Trump referred to migrant caravans as an “invasion” in an official White House address on November 1, 2018. A presidential proclamation issued January 20, 2025 used the framing of an invasion to support immigration restrictions and executive action. The repetition from public rhetoric to legal document is directly verifiable. It does not independently establish why each drafter chose the wording or resolve contested legal questions. [12] [13]
The Office of Remigration
The State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual, updated October 9, 2026, names an Office of Remigration (PRM/REM) and gives it coordination responsibilities concerning voluntary departure or involuntary removal of foreign nationals. The term also circulates in European far-right politics with sometimes much broader meanings. The official U.S. description concerns noncitizens; its scope must not be falsely equated with the broader extremist proposals without supporting policy documents. [23]
Afrikaner refugee admissions
Presidential determinations for fiscal 2026 explicitly prioritized certain Afrikaner refugee admissions. A subsequent May 2026 emergency determination increased the overall admissions ceiling. The original documents establish the policy choices and their stated legal basis. Whether the administration's evidence justified the distinctions, and whether policies had discriminatory effects, require independent legal and factual assessment. [24] [25]
6. The questions reached Congress and law-enforcement analysts
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse sought information about DHS recruitment materials and hiring safeguards. In June 2026 he referenced a Colorado law-enforcement intelligence bulletin that warned extremist groups might interpret federal recruitment language as encouragement. Reporting by The Intercept described that bulletin. A threat assessment is evidence that officials considered a risk, not proof that extremists were actually hired or acted because of an advertisement. [20] [21] [22]
Separately, a House congressional inquiry sought information from DHS and Labor about social-media posts criticized for white-supremacist associations. Together, these requests identify a concrete official record to examine: drafts, approvals, vendor contracts, recruitment screening, warnings received and any documented actions taken in response. [32]
Selected chronology
| Date | Record | Evidence category |
|---|---|---|
| May and Nov. 2017 | NCAI protests use of “Pocahontas”; archived White House transcript captures Code Talkers remarks. | First-party statements [1] [2] [3] |
| 2017–2018 | Miller, DOJ and ICE communications concerning speeches and immigration publicity. | FOIA-derived correspondence [9] [10] [11] |
| Nov. 2018 | Trump uses “invasion” language in White House border remarks. | Official transcript [12] |
| Jan. 2025 | Presidential proclamation uses invasion framing. | Official proclamation [13] |
| 2025–early 2026 | DHS, White House and Labor recruitment and visual communications questioned by researchers and lawmakers. | Reported posts and official inquiry [14] [15] [16] [32] |
| Oct. 9, 2026 | Office of Remigration documented in State Department manual. | Official organizational directive [23] |
| Nov. 15–16, 2026 | Reitz warning to Warren; grievance; separate Garcia letter reported; DOJ review requested. | Official correspondence and attributed reporting [4] [5] [6] [7] |
7. What remains to be proved
- Who wrote and approved the Warren warning? Obtain the original signed two-page copy within FTI's record system, the complete drafting chain, legal review, and any contemporaneous DOJ or White House communications. The formal letter's existence is established; its internal origin is not.
- Who authored the agency posts? Obtain design files, assets, approval logs, emails, vendor contracts and platform scheduling history for the identified DHS, Labor and White House advertisements.
- Were concerns raised internally? Identify documented warnings, decision-makers' responses, any removals, revisions or reassignments, and dates.
- Did messaging change staffing or public conduct? Obtain any releaseable recruitment data, vetting procedures, complaints, and law-enforcement assessments. Do not treat online praise by extremists as evidence of recruitment outcomes.
- What connects the two administrations? Compare named staff, communications vendors and recurring assets, then seek direct evidence of idea transfer rather than inferring it from similar slogans.
- What happened to the watchdog referrals? Verify any State Bar acceptance or action, DOJ response, and Warren's response to Reitz's November 23 preservation deadline, where public.
Working conclusion: The record documents recurring use of ethnic stereotypes in attacks on Warren; federal publication of material with associations identified by extremist researchers; and real historical coordination over immigration messaging. It does not yet establish a unified direction to communicate racist signals, a common author for the current posts, a prosecutorial crime, or the outcome of any pending ethics review. This investigation will be updated as original records resolve those questions.
Original records and cited reporting
References distinguish firsthand government or organizational publications from analysis and secondary reporting. FTI does not treat a press release, bar grievance, social-media post or cited allegation as an adjudicated finding. Some released FOIA documents are described through American Oversight's collection pages and have not all been page-audited. No source on this page links to Truth Social or its repost archives.
- NCAI, May 3, 2017 statement
- Archived White House, Navajo Code Talkers remarks, Nov. 27, 2017
- NCAI, Nov. 27, 2017 response
- FTI: The Threat Before the Subpoena, Nov. 16, 2026
- Campaign for Accountability, Texas Bar grievance announcement, Nov. 16, 2026
- CBS News, Reitz response and separate Garcia letter, Nov. 16, 2026
- The Steady State, DOJ referral announcement, Nov. 16, 2026
- Southern Poverty Law Center, Miller–Breitbart emails, Nov. 2019
- American Oversight, Miller's influence on immigration policy (FOIA record guide)
- American Oversight, Miller–ICE adviser communications, Jan. 2020
- American Oversight, Miller–DOJ speech/policy emails, Dec. 2020
- Archived White House, immigration remarks, Nov. 1, 2018
- White House, Jan. 20, 2025 proclamation on invasion
- JTA, DHS recruitment phrase and extremism associations, Aug. 2025
- SPLC, DHS/White House recruitment song provenance, Jan. 2026
- Associated Press, agency posts and DHS response, Jan. 2026
- CNN transcript, distinctions in slogan comparisons, Jan. 15, 2026
- JTA, Labor to DHS communications hiring, Feb. 12, 2026
- JTA, DHS speechwriter background, Aug. 20, 2025
- Sen. Whitehouse, DHS recruitment inquiry, Feb. 2026
- Sen. Whitehouse, follow-up, June 2026
- The Intercept, Colorado law-enforcement bulletin reporting, May 2026
- U.S. State Department Foreign Affairs Manual, Oct. 9, 2026
- Presidential determination, FY 2026 refugee admissions
- Emergency presidential determination, May 21, 2026
- Reuters, Obama depiction and response, Feb. 6, 2026
- Roll Call, full Charlottesville transcript, Aug. 15, 2017
- Archived White House, remarks concerning MS-13, May 2018
- Commission on Presidential Debates, Sept. 29, 2020 transcript
- Archived White House, Sept. 30, 2020 clarification
- PBS/AP, reposted video and White House response, June 2020
- House Democrats, DHS and Labor inquiry, Feb. 11, 2026
- Washington Post, July 2025 DHS historical image context
- NCAI contextual note on Indigenous heritage and Warren controversy
- SPLC: DHS recruitment patterns in official posts
Corrections and updates: New primary records will be incorporated with dated changes. Please use Corrections to flag a specific sentence or source.